Messianic Education Trust
- a Messianic Jewish Teaching Website


Who are we ?
Raison d'Être
Weekly Parasha
Contact Us
Kids' Website
Administration ...
To understand how we manage copyright, usage of the site and personal data, please read our Usage Policy and our Privacy Policy.

Read the Parasha Commentary for B"har 5776

Welcome to the Messianic Education Trust website! Here you can find details of the Trust, what it does, where it is and the way we are aiming to carry out our calling.

Each week we publish a commentary on the Torah portion, which you can read here or by clicking the button on the left 'Weekly Parasha'. All the texts used in the commentaries are fully indexed in the Scripture Index.

On the Books page you can see a selection of books that we recommend for study tools and can be bought through Amazon, ABE Books or other on-line merchants.

From our blog -- Tuesday, 24 May 2016

Memory and Identity in Ancient Judaism and Early Christianity,
Tom Thatcher ed., SBL, 2014, page 118

An essay by Dr Steven D. Fraade, professor of the History of Judaism at Yale, alerts us to the role of images and iconography in memorialising both loss and continuity in early Jewish history.

The Sifra and the Mishnah both record that in Second Temple times, the lulav - the palm frond, myrtle and willow bundle - and the etrog, a citron fruit, were only taken up and waved on the first day of the feast of Sukkot to fulfill the command: "On the first day you shall take ... and you shall rejoice before the L-rd your G-d seven days" (Vayikra/Leviticus 23:40). However, after the Second Temple was destroyed - by the Romans, the Hurban in 70 CE - instead of dropping the custom,

Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai made a run that in the provinces the lulav should be taken for seven days, as a memorial to the temple (Sifra Emor 16.9)

As long as the temple stood, Fraade explains, the lulav was taken on the first day for a literal fulfillment, and the seven days days rejoicing took place in the temple before the L-rd. Once the temple was destroyed, however, when coming up to Jerusalem to celebrate thefeast was no longer possible, taking the lulav for seven days "as a memorial of the temple" allowed the presence of the L-rd to be in the provinces as well. Fraade explains:

It should be noted that centuries later, in the iconography of the synagogue, the etrog and lulav commonly appear with ritual objects associated with the temple: holy ark, menorah, shofar and incense shovel. The association of the lulav with the temple did not cease with the latter's destruction but rather continued, with the visual representation of the lulav (among other ritual objects) preserving the memory and symbolic presence of the temple among synagogue worshipers, wherever they might be.

Posted By Jonathan, 8:07am Comment Comments: 0